Read the original article here.

---

The Logic Analyzer: Your Digital Microscope in Building a Computer From Scratch

Building a computer from its fundamental components is a rewarding but challenging endeavor. As you piece together logic gates, design memory interfaces, implement control logic, and wrestle with timing constraints, you'll inevitably encounter situations where signals aren't behaving as expected. A simple multimeter can tell you if a wire has continuity or a voltage level, and an oscilloscope is invaluable for looking at the shape and timing of one or two analog signals. However, digital systems, especially complex ones like a computer's CPU, memory, and peripherals, involve dozens or even hundreds of signals changing simultaneously. This is where the logic analyzer becomes an indispensable tool. Think of it as a specialized microscope that allows you to peer inside your digital circuit and see the state of many signals at once, frozen in time or unfolding step-by-step according to your system's clock.

What is a Logic Analyzer?

When debugging a digital circuit, you often need to know the logic level (high or low, 1 or 0) of many signals at precise moments. An oscilloscope, while powerful, is primarily designed for viewing analog waveforms and typically has only a few channels (usually 2 or 4). Trying to debug a 16-bit data bus and a 16-bit address bus, plus control signals, with an oscilloscope is impractical.

A logic analyzer is an electronic instrument that captures and displays multiple logic signals from a digital system or digital circuit. A logic analyzer may convert the capture into timing diagrams, protocol decodes, state machine traces, opcodes, or may correlate opcodes with source-level software. Logic analyzers have advanced triggering capabilities, and are useful when a user needs to see the timing relationships between many signals in a digital system.

In essence, a logic analyzer is a multi-channel digital data recorder. It doesn't care about the shape of the analog signal (like ringing or overshoot) as much as an oscilloscope does; it simply interprets the signal as a logical 0 or 1 based on predefined voltage thresholds. Its strength lies in its ability to monitor a large number of channels simultaneously and capture events based on complex digital conditions.

Why You Need a Logic Analyzer When Building a Computer

Building a computer involves understanding and verifying the behavior of various digital subsystems operating in concert:

1. CPU: Fetching instructions, reading/writing data to memory/I/O, responding to interrupts. This involves interacting with address, data, and control buses.
2. Memory (RAM/ROM): Responding to read/write requests, enabling/disabling based on addresses.
3. I/O Devices: Interacting with peripherals via specific protocols (like SPI, I2C, UART) or custom interfaces.
4. Control Logic: State machines that sequence operations (e.g., instruction decode, memory access cycles).
5. Clocking and Timing: Ensuring signals arrive and settle within the required timing windows relative to clock edges (setup and hold times).

Issues in these areas are often subtle timing problems, incorrect sequences of control signals, or data appearing on a bus at the wrong time or with the wrong value. An oscilloscope might show you a single clock signal or a data line, but it can't easily show you:

• What value was on the entire 16-bit data bus when the read enable signal went active and the address bus held a specific value?
• If your state machine correctly transitions through a sequence of states in response to inputs.
• The precise timing relationship between a peripheral's data output and your input latch signal across multiple bits.
• The sequence of bytes transferred during an I2C communication transaction.

A logic analyzer excels at these tasks by capturing the state of dozens of signals simultaneously and allowing you to trigger on specific, complex digital events.

Categories of Logic Analyzers

Logic analyzers come in various forms, differing primarily in their packaging, performance, and cost. For someone building a computer from scratch, especially as a hobbyist or student, the PC-based option is often the most accessible entry point.

1. Modular Logic Analyzers: These are high-performance systems typically used in professional environments. They consist of a mainframe or chassis that houses the display, controls, and processing power, and separate modules that contain the actual data acquisition hardware. You can add more modules to increase the channel count significantly (hundreds of channels are possible). While offering top-tier performance (sampling speed, memory depth) and flexibility, they are generally the most expensive option. For complex, high-speed custom CPU designs or large ASIC/FPGA debugging, their performance might be necessary, but they are often overkill (and cost-prohibitive) for educational projects using discrete logic or microcontrollers.

2. Portable Logic Analyzers: Also known as standalone logic analyzers, these integrate the display, controls, and data acquisition hardware into a single, self-contained unit. They offer a good balance of performance and portability and are often found on lab benches for general-purpose digital debugging. They are typically less expensive than modular systems but offer fewer channels and less ultimate performance compared to the high-end modular units. They are a viable option if budget allows and a dedicated, all-in-one solution is preferred.

3. PC-Based Logic Analyzers: These systems consist of a hardware device that connects to a computer (usually via USB or Ethernet) and software that runs on the PC for configuration, data display, and analysis. The PC provides the user interface, processing power, and storage.

   • Advantages for computer building: They are significantly less expensive than standalone or modular units, making them very accessible for hobbyists and educational purposes. They leverage the PC's large display, keyboard, and processing power, leading to a user-friendly interface and often powerful analysis features in the software. Their small size makes them easy to set up on a crowded workbench.
   • Considerations: Performance (maximum sampling speed, memory depth) can vary widely between models and might be lower than high-end standalone or modular units. The software's quality and features are crucial.

Operation: How to Use This Powerful Tool

Using a logic analyzer effectively involves several key steps:

Connecting the Probes

This is often the most tedious part, especially with a high channel count. Each signal you want to monitor requires a separate probe connection.

• Traditional Clips: The most common method involves small clips that attach to IC pins, header pins, or wires. These can be prone to accidentally detaching or shorting adjacent pins if not careful.
• Specialized Connectors: Many development boards and professional systems include dedicated connectors (sometimes called "logic analyzer headers") that allow a single cable bundle to connect to multiple test points, simplifying setup.
• Connectorless Probing: High-end systems sometimes use technologies (like compression or soft-touch probes) that make contact directly with pads on the PCB without requiring a physical connector. This is less common for hobbyist-level projects but offers extremely low electrical loading.

Regardless of the probe type, it's crucial to minimize the electrical load your probes place on the circuit under test. Excessive probing can alter the circuit's behavior, leading to frustrating "probe effects" where the problem disappears when you try to measure it. Modern probes are designed for very low capacitance (e.g., < 1 pF per signal) to mitigate this. You will also need to connect ground wires from the logic analyzer to the ground reference of your circuit.

Setting Up Signals and Grouping

Once connected, you configure the logic analyzer software. This involves:

• Assigning Names: Giving meaningful names to each channel (e.g., CLOCK, RESET, ADDRESS_0, DATA_7, MEM_READ_EN). This makes interpreting the captured data much easier than just looking at Channel 0, Channel 1, etc.
• Grouping Signals: You can group related signals together. For example, you might group all the ADDRESS_ lines into a bus called ADDRESS and configure the software to display its value as a hexadecimal number rather than 16 individual bits. Similarly, group DATA_ lines into a DATA bus. This significantly cleans up the display.

Choosing a Capture Mode: Timing vs. State

This is a critical distinction in logic analysis and fundamental to understanding digital systems.

• Timing Mode: In timing mode, the logic analyzer samples the state of all configured input channels at regular, fixed intervals based on its own internal clock generator (or sometimes an external clock source, though less common for basic timing mode).

  Timing Mode: Captures signal states based on the logic analyzer's internal, high-speed clock, providing a view of signal transitions over continuous time. Useful for analyzing transient events, glitches, setup/hold violations, and overall signal sequencing speed. This mode is like a multi-channel oscilloscope display for digital signals. You see the waveforms and their relative timing. It's essential for debugging:

  • Timing Violations: Checking if signals meet setup and hold time requirements relative to a clock edge.
  • Glitches: Detecting very short pulses that might cause incorrect behavior.
  • Propagation Delays: Measuring the delay between a stimulus (like a clock edge or input change) and a response.
  • Asynchronous Signals: Examining signals that are not synchronized to your main system clock.

• State Mode: In state mode, the logic analyzer samples the input signals only when a specific clock signal (provided by your circuit under test) transitions (e.g., rising or falling edge). You designate one or more of your input signals as clock sources for the analyzer. You can also use other input signals as "qualifiers," meaning the clock edge is only used for sampling if the qualifier signals meet certain conditions (e.g., only sample on the clock rising edge if the MEM_READ_EN signal is low).

  State Mode: Captures signal states only on specified clock edges from the circuit under test. Provides a view of the system's "state" at each clock cycle, ideal for following synchronous bus transactions, state machine execution, and instruction flows. This mode effectively shows you the stable state of your system at each active clock edge. It's invaluable for debugging:

  • Bus Transactions: Following values on address, data, and control buses cycle by cycle.
  • State Machine Execution: Verifying that your control logic moves through the correct sequence of states.
  • Instruction Flow: Observing the state of the CPU's buses as it fetches and executes instructions (if you have access to those signals).
  • Synchronous Logic: Verifying the values of registers or outputs after a clock edge.

For building a CPU and related synchronous logic, state mode is often more powerful than timing mode because it directly shows you what the system was doing at each clock cycle, filtering out the noise and transitions that happen between stable states. However, timing mode is crucial when you suspect problems with the clock signal itself, signal integrity, or asynchronous interactions. Many logic analyzers can run both modes simultaneously or switch between views of the same captured data.

Setting the Trigger Condition

This is where logic analyzers truly shine compared to simpler tools. A trigger condition tells the analyzer when to start capturing data (or sometimes, stop capturing data). Without a trigger, you'd just capture a random chunk of time. With a trigger, you can capture the data precisely around the event you want to investigate.

• Simple Triggers: Triggering on a single signal's rising or falling edge.
• Pattern Triggers: Triggering when a specific pattern of 0s and 1s appears across multiple channels (e.g., trigger when MEM_WRITE_EN is active AND ADDRESS bus equals 0xFF00).
• Sequence Triggers: Triggering only after a specific sequence of patterns occurs (e.g., trigger after you see RESET go high, followed by a read from address 0x0000). This is powerful for finding issues that only happen after a specific setup sequence.
• Protocol Triggers: Many analyzers, especially with protocol decoding software, can trigger on specific events within a communication protocol (e.g., trigger on an I2C transaction targeting a specific device address, or a UART receive error).
• Range Triggers: Triggering when a signal or bus value enters or leaves a specified range (e.g., trigger if the ADDRESS bus is between 0x1000 and 0x1FFF).

For computer building, complex triggers are invaluable. You might trigger on:

• An instruction fetch from a specific memory location.
• A write operation to an I/O port.
• A particular state in your control logic state machine.
• An unexpected condition, like a read from a memory region that should only be written to.

You typically specify how much data to capture before and after the trigger event. This allows you to see the events leading up to the problem and the immediate consequences.

Running and Capturing Data

Once the probes are connected, signals are configured, mode is chosen, and a trigger is set, you set the analyzer to "run." It monitors the input signals, waiting for the trigger condition. When the trigger occurs, it captures the specified amount of data into its internal memory. Most analyzers can be set to trigger once and stop, or to trigger repeatedly, which is useful for capturing intermittent problems or comparing multiple cycles of an operation.

Displaying and Interpreting Data

After capture, the data is uploaded to the PC software (for PC-based and some modular systems) or displayed on the standalone unit's screen. The data can be viewed in several ways:

• Timing Diagram: Shows the signals as waveforms over time, similar to an oscilloscope but with many more channels. This is the primary view for timing mode data and can also show state mode data represented as waveforms.
• State Listing: Displays the captured data as a table, where each row represents a clock cycle (in state mode) or a sampling point (in timing mode), and each column shows the value of a signal or bus at that point. This is the most common view for state mode data and is excellent for following bus values cycle-by-cycle. The software can often display bus values in binary, hexadecimal, decimal, or even ASCII.
• Protocol Decode: For standard serial protocols (SPI, I2C, UART, etc.), the software can often interpret the raw captured bits and display them as decoded packets or transactions, showing the protocol events, addresses, and data in a human-readable format. Some advanced analyzers can even decode parallel bus transactions or instruction opcodes if you configure them correctly based on your CPU architecture.
• Comparison Mode: Many analyzers can compare a newly captured dataset against a previously saved "golden" dataset. This is useful for long-term testing or verifying that changes you made didn't break existing functionality. The analyzer can highlight differences or stop the capture when a difference is detected.

For someone building a computer, learning to read and interpret state listings and timing diagrams is crucial. Seeing the values on the address and data buses change with respect to control signals (like MEM_READ_EN, WRITE_EN, CLOCK) is fundamental to verifying your CPU and memory interface logic.

Applications in Building Your Computer from Scratch

Here are specific ways a logic analyzer helps in your computer building project:

• Verifying Basic Logic: Debugging simple combinational or sequential logic blocks you design (adders, decoders, latches, registers).
• Debugging Bus Interfaces: Observing transactions on the address, data, and control buses connecting your CPU, memory, and I/O. Is the correct address appearing? Is the data valid when the read/write strobe is active? Is the memory controller asserting the correct chip select?
• Analyzing State Machines: Tracking the sequence of states in your control logic to ensure it's following the designed flow (e.g., during instruction fetch, decode, execute cycles).
• Debugging Memory Interaction: Verifying that your memory read and write cycles adhere to the timing specifications of your RAM or ROM chips.
• Debugging I/O Communication: Using protocol decoding to verify communication with peripherals over interfaces like SPI (SD card, display), I2C (sensors, EEPROM), or UART (serial console). Even if your bus is custom, you can often set up the analyzer to display the data in a bus-like format.
• Clock and Timing Analysis: While less detailed on analog characteristics than an oscilloscope, timing mode can show clock glitches or gross timing errors between related signals.
• FPGA Development: If you're implementing parts of your computer (like the CPU or memory controller) in an FPGA, a logic analyzer (or integrated logic analysis tools like Xilinx's ChipScope or Intel's SignalTap) is essential for debugging the synthesized hardware within the FPGA.

Historical Context

The logic analyzer emerged in the early 1970s precisely because the needs of digital system designers outgrew the capabilities of the oscilloscope. As digital circuits became more complex with the advent of integrated circuits and microprocessors, engineers needed to view many digital signals simultaneously and trigger on complex digital events. Early logic analyzers were pioneers in displaying multiple digital waveforms or state listings, directly addressing the unique challenges of debugging the first microprocessors and digital systems.

Related Tools: Mixed-Signal Oscilloscopes (MSOs)

You might encounter Mixed-Signal Oscilloscopes (MSOs). These instruments combine the features of a traditional digital storage oscilloscope (DSO) with a limited number of logic analyzer channels (typically 8 or 16).

• Benefit: The major advantage is the ability to view both analog waveforms (e.g., power supply ripple, signal integrity issues on one or two key lines, clock signal quality) and multiple digital signals time-correlated on the same screen. You can trigger on an analog event and see the digital consequences, or vice versa.
• Limitations: MSOs typically have far fewer digital channels than a dedicated logic analyzer. They also often lack the deep memory and advanced state analysis capabilities (like complex state machine triggering or sophisticated protocol decoding) found in dedicated logic analyzers. For serious, high-channel-count digital debugging or detailed state analysis of a complex bus, a dedicated logic analyzer is usually necessary. However, for debugging interactions between the analog and digital parts of a system, or for projects requiring only a moderate number of digital channels alongside analog views, an MSO can be a very useful tool.

Conclusion

As you delve into the fascinating "Lost Art of Building a Computer from Scratch," you'll move beyond the abstract world of logic diagrams and into the practical challenges of physical hardware. Here, theory meets reality, and signals don't always behave as planned. The logic analyzer is your essential tool for understanding this reality. It provides the visibility into the synchronous and asynchronous behavior of your digital logic that is necessary to diagnose problems, verify your designs, and ultimately bring your handmade computer to life. Learning to effectively use a logic analyzer is as fundamental a skill for the digital hardware builder as learning to read schematics or wield a soldering iron.